Last Updated : GMT 06:22:25
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today
Home » TV

Reality TV show sparks row over welfare dependency

Arab Today, arab today

Arab Today, arab today Reality TV show sparks row over welfare dependency

London - AFP

The welfare system was the pride of post-war Britain, but the reaction to the incendiary reality television programme "Benefits Street" is showing how much times have changed. The show revolves around a real residential road in Birmingham, which has an unemployment rate at 16.5 percent -- double the national average. Viewed by five million people each week, the Channel 4 series has inflamed an already febrile national debate about welfare culture and the lifestyles of those living on state handouts. The five, hour-long episodes, screened on Monday nights, revolve around James Turner Street, which the producers say is one of the most welfare-dependent in Britain. The portrayal is unflattering. A petty thief reveals how to get away with stealing clothes from shops; a couple merrily confess to being caught cheating the benefits system; and one woman who had not paid the rent shows aggression to the man delivering her eviction notice. Residents in filthy, trash-strewn houses constantly come and go and if anyone in the street does have a job, there is no news of them. Some residents feel betrayed by the programme. "They told us that they wanted to capture the community spirit of James Turner Street and show the positive of that but all they have done is show the negative," Dean Oakes told the BB'Get a job you dogs'Each episode sparks a huge reaction on social networks. Those defending the welfare system see a cruel caricature, while critics see all their objections made manifest. "Just watched benefits street what a bunch of lowlife scum a bullet costs about 30p so we could sort the street out and have change from £20," wrote Twitter user @garryturner4. User @sasharabella wrote: "Watching the scum on this Benefits Street programme infuriates me. Get a job you dogs." On the other extreme, more than 30,000 people have signed an e-petition calling for the show to be taken off air. "It is creating a skewed image of a section of society and stirring up hatred," it reads. The broadcasting watchdog Ofcom says it has received hundreds of complaints. Channel 4, a private channel with a long history of controversial programming, has insisted "Benefits Street" is exactly the sort of documentary it should be making. "No programme on this subject will satisfy everyone, but the furore surrounding it reinforces my view that we should absolutely be making programmes in this territory," said head of documentaries Nick Mirsky. "To avoid or sanitise the day-to-day realities would be a dereliction of our remit." 'Projecting the extreme cases' The furore has even reached parliament. Work and Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith told lawmakers on Monday that viewers were rightly "shocked", and therefore backed reforms "to end these abuses". His department is slashing state hand-outs and going after fraudulent claimants with a campaign warning: "Benefit thieves: it's not if we catch you, it's when". Latest figures show Britain spent 7,641 euros ($10,430) per person on social protection in 2011, according to Eurostat, the European Union's statistics hub That is slightly above the EU average of 7,290 euros but far behind front-runners Luxembourg with 18,136 euros, Denmark with 14,785 euros and the 10,300 euros spent by France, a country of similar size to Britain. Finance minister George Osborne is trying to reduce Britain's huge deficit and last week said a further £12 billion ($20 billion, 24 billion euros) of welfare cuts were needed between 2015 and 2017. "Where is the fairness, we ask, for the shift-worker, leaving home in the dark hours of the early morning, who looks up at the closed blinds of their next door neighbour sleeping off a life on benefits?" he asked, in his Conservative Party conference speech in October. "Benefits Street" has given the debate focus by personalising the issue. Opposition Labour Party lawmaker Anne Begg, who chairs parliament's work and pensions scrutiny committee, said there was a "huge imbalance" in the show. "Part of the problem of projecting the extreme cases is that people then extrapolate that and say that applies to everybody who is on benefits," she told the BBC. "There wasn't anybody who was a typical benefit claimant featured on the programme at all." She added: "Half of people who are on benefits are actually in work. Benefits and social security payments don't just go to people who are out of work." John Bird, who founded The Big Issue homelessness magazine, said it was time to face up to the reality of "Benefits Street" -- that the welfare system traps people in poverty. "The portrayal of claimants is not an uplifting one, but that's because life on benefits is soul-destroying," he wrote in the Daily Mail newspaper. "It actually provides perverse incentives towards idleness.

Name *

E-mail *

Comment Title*

Comment *

: Characters Left

Mandatory *

Terms of use

Publishing Terms: Not to offend the author, or to persons or sanctities or attacking religions or divine self. And stay away from sectarian and racial incitement and insults.

I agree with the Terms of Use

Security Code*

Arab Today, arab today reality tv show sparks row over welfare dependency Arab Today, arab today reality tv show sparks row over welfare dependency


Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today Adidas Originals ‘reinterpreted’

GMT 14:52 2016 Thursday ,01 December

Adidas Originals ‘reinterpreted’
Arab Today, arab today Ajman Tourism launches time capsule

GMT 13:17 2016 Friday ,25 November

Ajman Tourism launches time capsule
Arab Today, arab today Paris's matchbox apartments

GMT 10:37 2016 Saturday ,24 September

Paris's matchbox apartments
Arab Today, arab today US-led coalition admits 54 deaths

GMT 08:47 2016 Friday ,02 December

US-led coalition admits 54 deaths
Arab Today, arab today French satire mag hits Germany

GMT 09:52 2016 Thursday ,01 December

French satire mag hits Germany
View News in Arabic - Media: تلفزيون
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today Dino-killing crater shows clues

GMT 14:43 2016 Thursday ,24 November

Dino-killing crater shows clues
Arab Today, arab today Punk memorabilia torched

GMT 13:52 2016 Monday ,28 November

Punk memorabilia torched
Arab Today, arab today Green groups pressure Spain

GMT 13:01 2016 Thursday ,01 December

Green groups pressure Spain
Arab Today, arab today Pluto's unruly moons

GMT 06:31 2015 Thursday ,04 June

Pluto's unruly moons
Arab Today, arab today Hyundai allows Saudi journalists

GMT 15:14 2016 Thursday ,01 December

Hyundai allows Saudi journalists
Arab Today, arab today Latest Infiniti QX to compete

GMT 13:16 2016 Saturday ,26 November

Latest Infiniti QX to compete
Arab Today, arab today To find German funny bone

GMT 12:45 2016 Tuesday ,29 November

To find German funny bone
Arab Today, arab today Car manufacturers to power Europe

GMT 13:01 2016 Tuesday ,29 November

Car manufacturers to power Europe

GMT 08:49 2016 Monday ,28 November

Israeli Arab rapper's music provokes

GMT 11:55 2016 Monday ,21 November

Amal Al-Qubaisi attends reception

GMT 04:15 2016 Thursday ,30 June

World's largest uncut diamond fails

GMT 12:39 2016 Friday ,25 November

Arctic 9-12C above normal

GMT 15:59 2015 Wednesday ,27 May

Seoul elevates gardening to high art

GMT 12:39 2016 Saturday ,26 November

Skin patch could help kids

GMT 09:35 2016 Saturday ,19 November

Hyperloop One settles co-founder

GMT 13:12 2015 Saturday ,09 May

Sheikh Sultan opens Sharjah Centre

GMT 09:53 2016 Sunday ,15 May

OMEGA official timekeepers
Arab Today, arab today
Arab Today, arab today
 Arab Today Facebook,arab today facebook  Arab Today Twitter,arab today twitter Arab Today Rss,arab today rss  Arab Today Youtube,arab today youtube  Arab Today Youtube,arab today youtube

Powered and Developed by FilmMatters

Copyright © 2016 Arabtoday

Developed by FilmMatters

© 2016 Arabtoday

arabtoday arabtoday arabtoday
بناية النخيل - رأس النبع _ خلف السفارة الفرنسية _بيروت - لبنان
arabtoday, Arabtoday, Arabtoday